Artboard 1? alert-icon? Artboard 1? ? ? delete-icon? edit-icon? email-icon hide-hover-icon? Artboard 1? login-icon-white Artboard 1? next-icon-left next-icon-right-left next-icon-left-ochre next-icon next-icon-right-grey next-icon-right-ochre plus-with-circle-iconP search-fw-icon? search-icon-ochre search-icon-white
×

Select Language

Banyan Bay

A subdivision of Stuart.

Total Homes : 187

Percentage Available: 2.7 %

Gated : Yes

Club Membership : No

No-Fee Community : No

Banyan Bay, Stuart, FL Homes for Sale

LOCATION PRICE BEDS BATHS $/SQFT
4602 SW Millbrook Lane | Banyan Bay $990,000 5 3/1 $309 -
5073 SW Winchester Drive | Banyan Bay $1,279,990 4 3/1 $419 -
614 SW Pennfield Terrace | Banyan Bay Pud Phase 2 $950,000 3 2/1 $448 -
5012 SW Winchester Drive | Banyan Bay Pud Phase 2a & 2b $1,125,000 3 2/1 $447 -
654 SW Pennfield Terrace | Banyan Bay Pud Ph 2a & 2b $1,165,000 3 3/1 $424 -
4973 SW Winchester Drive | Banyan Bay Pud Phase 2a & 2b $1,100,000 3 2/1 $432 -
5083 SW Winchester Drive | Banyan Bay Pud Ph 2a&2b $1,020,000 5 5 $344 -
4853 SW Millbrook Lane | Banyan Bay Ph 01 $1,100,000 3 2/1 $420 -
4701 SW Ardsley Drive | Banyan Bay Pud $1,060,000 4 3/1 $364 -
4802 SW Millbrook Lane | Banyan Bay $989,900 3 3/1 $379 -
4751 SW Ardsley Drive | Banyan Bay Pud Phase 2a & 2b $947,500 4 3/1 $333 -
4700 SW Ardsley Drive | Banyan Bay Pud Ph 2a & 2b $901,000 4 2/1 $321 -
4852 SW Millbrook Lane | Banyan Bay Pud Phase 1 $890,000 4 3/1 $305 -
152 SW Pomeroy Street | Banyan Bay Pud Phase 2c $785,000 3 2/1 $347 -
4592 SW Millbrook Lane | Banyan Bay $780,000 3 3 $365 -
4672 SW Millbrook Lane | Banyan Bay Ph 01 $775,000 3 2 $394 -
4862 SW Millbrook Lane | Banyan Bay $759,000 3 3 $347 -
4670 SW Ardsley Dr | Banyan Bay $759,000 4 2 $375 -
4862 SW Millbrook Lane | Banyan Bay $759,000 3 3 $347 -
4620 SW Ardsley Drive | Banyan Bay Pud Ph 2a & 2b $700,000 3 3 $331 -
4713 SW Briarwood Court | Banyan Bay Ph 01 $701,000 3 3 $330 -
163 SW Pomeroy Street | Banyan Bay $690,400 5 3 $254 -
4914 SW Montclair Drive | Banyan Bay $675,000 4 3 $345 -
163 SW Pomeroy Street | Banyan Bay Pud Phase 2c $706,000 5 3 $231 -
4720 SW Ardsley Drive | Banyan Bay Pud Phase 2a & 2b $5,000/mo 3 3/1 $2 -
4770 SW Ardsley Drive | Banyan Bay $5,200/mo 4 2/1 $2 -
4823 SW Millbrook Lane | Banyan Bay Ph 01 $4,500/mo 3 3 $3 -
4660 SW Ardsley Drive | Banyan Bay $4,000/mo 4 4 $2 -
4660 SW Ardsley Drive | Banyan Bay $4,000/mo 4 4 $2 -
4914 SW Montclair Drive | Banyan Bay Ph 01 $3,500/mo 4 3 $2 -
4904 SW Montclair Drive | Banyan Bay Pud Ph 1 $3,600/mo 4 3/1 $2 -
4813 SW Millbrook Lane | Banyan Bay $3,500/mo 2 2 $3 -

684 SW Pennfield Terrace | Banyan Bay Pud Phase 2a & 2b

$1,099,990

4 beds, 3/1 baths, 2,971sqft, $371/sqft

4842 SW Millbrook Lane | Banyan Bay

$949,900

4 beds, 2/1 baths, 2,978sqft, $319/sqft

4764 SW Briarwood Ct | Banyan Bay

$899,999

4 beds, 3/1 baths, 2,918sqft, $309/sqft

4710 SW Ardsley Dr | Banyan Bay Pud Phase 2a &

$775,000

3 beds, 3 baths, 2,196sqft, $353/sqft

4630 SW Ardsley Drive | Banyan Bay Pud Phase 2a & 2b

$725,000

3 beds, 2 baths, 2,008sqft, $362/sqft

684 SW Pennfield Terrace | Banyan Bay Pud Phase 2a & 2b

$1,099,990

4 beds, 3/1 baths, 2,971sqft, $371/sqft

4842 SW Millbrook Lane | Banyan Bay

$949,900

4 beds, 2/1 baths, 2,978sqft, $319/sqft

4764 SW Briarwood Ct | Banyan Bay

$899,999

4 beds, 3/1 baths, 2,918sqft, $309/sqft

4710 SW Ardsley Dr | Banyan Bay Pud Phase 2a &

$775,000

3 beds, 3 baths, 2,196sqft, $353/sqft

4630 SW Ardsley Drive | Banyan Bay Pud Phase 2a & 2b

$725,000

3 beds, 2 baths, 2,008sqft, $362/sqft

4602 SW Millbrook Lane | Banyan Bay

$990,000

5 beds, 3/1 baths, 3,245sqft, $309/sqft

5073 SW Winchester Drive | Banyan Bay

$1,279,990

4 beds, 3/1 baths, 3,107sqft, $419/sqft

614 SW Pennfield Terrace | Banyan Bay Pud Phase 2

$950,000

3 beds, 2/1 baths, 2,668sqft, $448/sqft

5012 SW Winchester Drive | Banyan Bay Pud Phase 2a & 2b

$1,125,000

3 beds, 2/1 baths, 2,668sqft, $447/sqft

654 SW Pennfield Terrace | Banyan Bay Pud Ph 2a & 2b

$1,165,000

3 beds, 3/1 baths, 2,800sqft, $424/sqft

4973 SW Winchester Drive | Banyan Bay Pud Phase 2a & 2b

$1,100,000

3 beds, 2/1 baths, 2,668sqft, $432/sqft

5083 SW Winchester Drive | Banyan Bay Pud Ph 2a&2b

$1,020,000

5 beds, 5 baths, 3,278sqft, $344/sqft

4853 SW Millbrook Lane | Banyan Bay Ph 01

$1,100,000

3 beds, 2/1 baths, 2,668sqft, $420/sqft

4701 SW Ardsley Drive | Banyan Bay Pud

$1,060,000

4 beds, 3/1 baths, 2,968sqft, $364/sqft

4802 SW Millbrook Lane | Banyan Bay

$989,900

3 beds, 3/1 baths, 2,616sqft, $379/sqft

4751 SW Ardsley Drive | Banyan Bay Pud Phase 2a & 2b

$947,500

4 beds, 3/1 baths, 2,933sqft, $333/sqft

4700 SW Ardsley Drive | Banyan Bay Pud Ph 2a & 2b

$901,000

4 beds, 2/1 baths, 2,958sqft, $321/sqft

4852 SW Millbrook Lane | Banyan Bay Pud Phase 1

$890,000

4 beds, 3/1 baths, 2,958sqft, $305/sqft

152 SW Pomeroy Street | Banyan Bay Pud Phase 2c

$785,000

3 beds, 2/1 baths, 2,363sqft, $347/sqft

4592 SW Millbrook Lane | Banyan Bay

$780,000

3 beds, 3 baths, 2,193sqft, $365/sqft

4672 SW Millbrook Lane | Banyan Bay Ph 01

$775,000

3 beds, 2 baths, 2,008sqft, $394/sqft

4862 SW Millbrook Lane | Banyan Bay

$759,000

3 beds, 3 baths, 2,193sqft, $347/sqft

4670 SW Ardsley Dr | Banyan Bay

$759,000

4 beds, 2 baths, 2,031sqft, $375/sqft

4862 SW Millbrook Lane | Banyan Bay

$759,000

3 beds, 3 baths, 2,193sqft, $347/sqft

4620 SW Ardsley Drive | Banyan Bay Pud Ph 2a & 2b

$700,000

3 beds, 3 baths, 2,196sqft, $331/sqft

4713 SW Briarwood Court | Banyan Bay Ph 01

$701,000

3 beds, 3 baths, 2,186sqft, $330/sqft

163 SW Pomeroy Street | Banyan Bay

$690,400

5 beds, 3 baths, 2,797sqft, $254/sqft

4914 SW Montclair Drive | Banyan Bay

$675,000

4 beds, 3 baths, 2,031sqft, $345/sqft

163 SW Pomeroy Street | Banyan Bay Pud Phase 2c

$706,000

5 beds, 3 baths, 2,988sqft, $231/sqft

4720 SW Ardsley Drive | Banyan Bay Pud Phase 2a & 2b

$5,000/mo

3 beds, 3/1 baths, 2,592sqft, $2/sqft

4770 SW Ardsley Drive | Banyan Bay

$5,200/mo

4 beds, 2/1 baths, 2,878sqft, $2/sqft

4823 SW Millbrook Lane | Banyan Bay Ph 01

$4,500/mo

3 beds, 3 baths, 2,193sqft, $3/sqft

4660 SW Ardsley Drive | Banyan Bay

$4,000/mo

4 beds, 4 baths, 2,592sqft, $2/sqft

4660 SW Ardsley Drive | Banyan Bay

$4,000/mo

4 beds, 4 baths, 2,592sqft, $2/sqft

4914 SW Montclair Drive | Banyan Bay Ph 01

$3,500/mo

4 beds, 3 baths, 2,031sqft, $2/sqft

4904 SW Montclair Drive | Banyan Bay Pud Ph 1

$3,600/mo

4 beds, 3/1 baths, 3,275sqft, $2/sqft

4813 SW Millbrook Lane | Banyan Bay

$3,500/mo

2 beds, 2 baths, 1,712sqft, $3/sqft

Banyan Bay Map

Loading map...

Welcome to Banyan Bay in Stuart, FL 

Living in Banyan Bay in Stuart, Florida, is peaceful and gorgeous. It is tucked away amidst 250 acres of protected preserve. This gated community, which was constructed in 2018, has 187 single-family homes that are artfully blended into the natural surroundings. The lush surroundings, gorgeous views of the beach, and seductive sunsets that await residents make every day feel like a refuge. Banyan Bay offers its residents the ideal mix because it was created for people who value elegance and the outdoors. In addition to these facilities, Banyan Bay has a game room, gym center, picnic area, clubhouse, and pool. There are also well planned walking trails throughout the community that are perfect for jogs in the early morning or evening strolls. Parks and playgrounds are great for families because there are several of them around where kids may play safely. Locals will have many opportunities to relax, be active, and socialize thanks to these facilities. 

Exquisite Homes and Living Spaces 

The 1,700–3,200 square foot homes in Banyan Bay come in a choice of floor plans to accommodate various tastes and lifestyles. There are six elegantly designed models available for prospective homeowners to select from, with two to five bedrooms and two to four bathrooms in each. With a maximum size of one acre, the roomy homesites offer plenty of area for outdoor activities and living. Comfort and elegance are of the utmost importance within these residences. Luxurious appliances and finishes in designer gourmet kitchens make cooking a pleasure, while roomy master bedrooms provide a peaceful haven. Modern fixtures and finishes combined with opulent bathrooms provide a spa-like atmosphere that makes every day seem special. With garage parking for up to three cars on the more spacious homesites, residents have ample space for their vehicles and storage needs. 

Convenient Access to Nearby Cities 

Banyan Bay’s prime location in Stuart, FL, offers residents convenient access to a variety of nearby cities and attractions. Stuart itself is a charming coastal town known for its vibrant downtown area, which features the iconic Sailfish Fountain, boutique stores, art galleries, cafes, and restaurants. The town provides a plethora of recreational options, including golf, tennis, water sports, hiking, and biking, making it an ideal place for those who enjoy an active lifestyle. 

Major highways make it easy to explore the surrounding areas. Travel north to Port St. Lucie for additional dining, shopping, and entertainment options, or head south to Tequesta for a quaint, small-town atmosphere. The Palm Beaches, including West Palm Beach, are also within easy reach, offering upscale shopping, cultural attractions, and beautiful beaches. Banyan Bay’s strategic location ensures that residents are never far from the best that South Florida has to offer. 

Banyan Bay stands out as a premier community in Stuart, FL, offering a perfect blend of luxury living, natural beauty, and convenient access to nearby attractions. Whether you are looking for a peaceful retreat or an active lifestyle, Banyan Bay has something to offer everyone. Explore the exquisite homes and amenities of Banyan Bay and discover why this community is the perfect place to call home. 

Banyan Bay Amenities 

  • clubhouse 
  • fitness center 
  • game room 
  • pool 
  • picnic area 
  • library 
  • sidewalks 

Banyan Bay FAQs 

Are there any recreational activities available in Banyan Bay? 

Yes, residents can enjoy various recreational activities including fitness workouts, swimming, and social events at the clubhouse. 

Are there any shopping and dining options nearby? 

Yes, downtown Stuart offers a variety of boutique stores, art galleries, cafes, and restaurants. Nearby cities also provide additional dining and shopping options. In addition, you can visit Kanner Crossing Shopping Plaza and Wedgewood Commons Shopping Center for even more retail and dining experiences. 

What schools are near Banyan Bay? 

Banyan Bay is located within the Martin County School District, which offers a range of highly rated schools for residents. The nearby schools include Pinewood Elementary School, Martin County High School, and Indian River State College Chastain Campus, providing excellent educational opportunities for families in the community. 

Can I find virtual tours of homes in Banyan Bay? 

Yes, virtual tours of homes in Banyan Bay are available for prospective buyers. For those interested, please contact an ECHO agent today! 

Banyan Bay Market Status

Banyan Bay, FL Market Report & Stats

Quick Community Stats for Banyan Bay Loading...

Percentage reflects Change

Updated for May May 2026 May 2025May 2024 % Diff
Avg Sold Price - -- --
New Properties on Market - -- --
Sold % of Ask Price - -- --
Avg Sold Price/SqFt - -- --
View All Communities

Ask Questions

Jeff Lichtenstein's Echo Fine Properties

ECHO FINE PROPERTIES

C 561-500-3246

O 561-500-3246

F 561-277-2500

Request More Info

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Your Soulmate in Real Estate™

Looking for a Perfect Community to live?

Take our step by step quiz to find a best matching community for you*.

* Patent Pending