Willoughby Cay

A subdivision of Stuart.

Total Homes : 54

Gated : No

Club Membership : No

No-Fee Community : No

See All Listings Active Homes for Sale>

See All Listings Active Homes for Sale

Willoughby Cay, Stuart, FL Homes for Sale

PENDING

46 Photos

1535 SE Tidewater Place Stuart, FL 34997

3 Beds / 2 Baths / 1,549 Sqft

$439,000

Willoughby Cay

PENDING

22 Photos

1499 SE Tidewater Place Stuart, FL 34997

2 Beds / 2 Baths / 1,416 Sqft

$435,000

Willoughby Cay

5 Photos

1589 SE Tidewater Place Stuart, FL 34997

2 Beds / 2 Baths / 1,549 Sqft

$409,000

Willoughby Cay

18 Photos

1594 SE Tidewater Place Stuart, FL 34997

3 Beds / 2 Baths / 1,549 Sqft

$2,750/mo

Willoughby Cay

36 Photos

1463 SE Tidewater Place Stuart, FL 34997

3 Beds / 2 Baths / 1,549 Sqft

$2,400/mo

Willoughby Cay

PENDING

46 Photos

1535 SE Tidewater Place Stuart, FL 34997

3 Beds / 2 Baths / 1,549 Sqft

$439,000

Willoughby Cay

PENDING

22 Photos

1499 SE Tidewater Place Stuart, FL 34997

2 Beds / 2 Baths / 1,416 Sqft

$435,000

Willoughby Cay

5 Photos

1589 SE Tidewater Place Stuart, FL 34997

2 Beds / 2 Baths / 1,549 Sqft

$409,000

Willoughby Cay

SOLD

34 Photos

4657 SE Bridgetown Court Stuart, FL 34997

2 Beds / 2 Baths / 1,549 Sqft

$316,000

Willoughby Cay

SOLD

37 Photos

4530 SE Bridgetown Court Stuart, FL 34997

3 Beds / 2 Baths / 1,549 Sqft

$452,500

Willoughby Cay

SOLD

36 Photos

4536 SE Bridgetown Court Stuart, FL 34997

2 Beds / 2 Baths / 1,549 Sqft

$420,000

Willoughby Cay

LOCATION	PRICE	BEDS	BATHS	$/SQFT
1535 SE Tidewater Place \| Willoughby Cay	$439,000	3	2	$284	-
1499 SE Tidewater Place \| Willoughby Cay	$435,000	2	2	$308	-
1589 SE Tidewater Place \| Willoughby Cay	$409,000	2	2	$265	-
4512 SE Bridgetown Court \| Willoughby (aka Willoughb	$385,000	3	2	$249	-
4609 SE Bridgetown Court \| Willoughby 18 Willoughby Cay	$365,000	2	2	$236	-

View All 5 Listings For Sale

	LOCATION	PRICE	BEDS	BATHS	$/SQFT
	1594 SE Tidewater Place \| Willoughby 18 Willoughby Cay	$2,750/mo	3	2	$2	-
	1463 SE Tidewater Place \| Willoughby (aka Willoughb	$2,400/mo	3	2	$2	-

View All 2 Rentals

LOCATION	PRICE	BEDS	BATHS	$/SQFT
1535 SE Tidewater Place \| Willoughby Cay	$439,000	3	2	$284	-
1499 SE Tidewater Place \| Willoughby Cay	$435,000	2	2	$308	-
1589 SE Tidewater Place \| Willoughby Cay	$409,000	2	2	$265	-
4512 SE Bridgetown Court \| Willoughby (aka Willoughb	$385,000	3	2	$249	-
4609 SE Bridgetown Court \| Willoughby 18 Willoughby Cay	$365,000	2	2	$236	-
1594 SE Tidewater Place \| Willoughby 18 Willoughby Cay	$2,750/mo	3	2	$2	-
1463 SE Tidewater Place \| Willoughby (aka Willoughb	$2,400/mo	3	2	$2	-

View All 7 Pending Listings

LOCATION	PRICE	BEDS	BATHS	$/SQFT
4657 SE Bridgetown Court \| Willoughby Cay	$316,000	2	2	$210	-
4530 SE Bridgetown Court \| Willoughby (aka Willoughb	$452,500	3	2	$307	-
4536 SE Bridgetown Court \| Willoughby 18 Willoughby Cay	$420,000	2	2	$291	-
4669 SE Bridgetown Court \| Willoughby Cay	$440,000	2	2	$315	-
4681 SE Bridgetown Court \| Willoughby Cay	$434,500	2	2	$286	-
4687 SE Bridgetown Court \| Willoughby 18 Willoughby Cay	$412,500	2	2	$304	-
4596 SE Bridgetown Court \| Willoughby Cay	$430,000	2	2	$278	-
4543 SE Bridgetown Court \| Willoughby 18 Willoughby Cay	$425,000	2	2	$275	-
4657 SE Bridgetown Court \| Willoughby Plat No 18 A P	$400,000	2	2	$272	-
4561 SE Bridgetown Court \| Willoughby Plat No 18 A P	$379,000	3	2	$259	-
4507 SE Bridgetown Court \| Willoughby Plat No 18 A P	$360,000	3	2	$258	-
4572 SE Bridgetown Court \| Willoughby Cay	$387,000	2	2	$258	-
4608 SE Bridgetown Court \| Willoughby Cay	$385,000	2	2	$256	-
4554 SE Bridgetown Court \| Willoughby Cay	$360,000	3	2	$249	-
4585 SE Bridgetown Ct \| Willoughby Plat No 18 A P	$375,000	3	2	$243	-
1589 SE Tidewater Place \| Willoughby Cay	$337,500	2	2	$239	-
1577 SE Tidewater Place \| Willoughby Plat No 18 A P	$335,000	2	2	$234	-
1458 SE Tidewater Place \| Willoughby 18 Willoughby Cay	$301,900	2	2	$201	-
1600 SE Tidewater Place \| Willoughby Plat No 18 A P	$3,500/mo	3	2	$3	-
1505 SE Tidewater Place \| Willoughby 18 Willoughby Cay	$3,000/mo	3	2	$3	-
1452 SE Tidewater Place \| Willoughby (aka Willoughb	$3,200/mo	3	2	$3	-
1505 SE Tidewater Place \| Willoughby 18 Willoughby Cay	$3,000/mo	3	2	$3	-
1446 SE Tidewater Place \| Willoughby Cay	$3,000/mo	3	2	$3	-
4531 SE Bridgetown Court \| Willoughby Cay	$2,900/mo	3	2	$2	-
1505 SE Tidewater Place \| Willoughby 18 Willoughby Cay	$3,000/mo	3	2	$2	-
4531 SE Bridgetown Court \| Willoughby 18 Willoughby Cay	$2,600/mo	3	2	$2	-
1517 SE Tidewater Place \| Willoughby Plat No 18 A P	$2,800/mo	3	2	$2	-
1517 SE Tidewater Place \| Willoughby Plat No 18 A P	$2,600/mo	3	2	$2	-

View All 28 Sold Listings

1535 SE Tidewater Place | Willoughby Cay

$439,000

3 beds, 2 baths, 1,549sqft, $284/sqft

1499 SE Tidewater Place | Willoughby Cay

$435,000

2 beds, 2 baths, 1,416sqft, $308/sqft

1589 SE Tidewater Place | Willoughby Cay

$409,000

2 beds, 2 baths, 1,549sqft, $265/sqft

4512 SE Bridgetown Court | Willoughby (aka Willoughb

$385,000

3 beds, 2 baths, 1,549sqft, $249/sqft

4609 SE Bridgetown Court | Willoughby 18 Willoughby Cay

$365,000

2 beds, 2 baths, 1,549sqft, $236/sqft

View All 5 Listings For Sale

1594 SE Tidewater Place | Willoughby 18 Willoughby Cay

$2,750/mo

3 beds, 2 baths, 1,549sqft, $2/sqft

1463 SE Tidewater Place | Willoughby (aka Willoughb

$2,400/mo

3 beds, 2 baths, 1,549sqft, $2/sqft

View All 2 Rentals

1535 SE Tidewater Place | Willoughby Cay

$439,000

3 beds, 2 baths, 1,549sqft, $284/sqft

1499 SE Tidewater Place | Willoughby Cay

$435,000

2 beds, 2 baths, 1,416sqft, $308/sqft

1589 SE Tidewater Place | Willoughby Cay

$409,000

2 beds, 2 baths, 1,549sqft, $265/sqft

4512 SE Bridgetown Court | Willoughby (aka Willoughb

$385,000

3 beds, 2 baths, 1,549sqft, $249/sqft

4609 SE Bridgetown Court | Willoughby 18 Willoughby Cay

$365,000

2 beds, 2 baths, 1,549sqft, $236/sqft

1594 SE Tidewater Place | Willoughby 18 Willoughby Cay

$2,750/mo

3 beds, 2 baths, 1,549sqft, $2/sqft

1463 SE Tidewater Place | Willoughby (aka Willoughb

$2,400/mo

3 beds, 2 baths, 1,549sqft, $2/sqft

View All 7 Pending Listings

4657 SE Bridgetown Court | Willoughby Cay

$316,000

2 beds, 2 baths, 1,549sqft, $210/sqft

4530 SE Bridgetown Court | Willoughby (aka Willoughb

$452,500

3 beds, 2 baths, 1,549sqft, $307/sqft

4536 SE Bridgetown Court | Willoughby 18 Willoughby Cay

$420,000

2 beds, 2 baths, 1,549sqft, $291/sqft

4669 SE Bridgetown Court | Willoughby Cay

$440,000

2 beds, 2 baths, 1,416sqft, $315/sqft

4681 SE Bridgetown Court | Willoughby Cay

$434,500

2 beds, 2 baths, 1,549sqft, $286/sqft

4687 SE Bridgetown Court | Willoughby 18 Willoughby Cay

$412,500

2 beds, 2 baths, 1,416sqft, $304/sqft

4596 SE Bridgetown Court | Willoughby Cay

$430,000

2 beds, 2 baths, 1,549sqft, $278/sqft

4543 SE Bridgetown Court | Willoughby 18 Willoughby Cay

$425,000

2 beds, 2 baths, 1,549sqft, $275/sqft

4657 SE Bridgetown Court | Willoughby Plat No 18 A P

$400,000

2 beds, 2 baths, 1,549sqft, $272/sqft

4561 SE Bridgetown Court | Willoughby Plat No 18 A P

$379,000

3 beds, 2 baths, 1,549sqft, $259/sqft

4507 SE Bridgetown Court | Willoughby Plat No 18 A P

$360,000

3 beds, 2 baths, 1,549sqft, $258/sqft

4572 SE Bridgetown Court | Willoughby Cay

$387,000

2 beds, 2 baths, 1,549sqft, $258/sqft

4608 SE Bridgetown Court | Willoughby Cay

$385,000

2 beds, 2 baths, 1,549sqft, $256/sqft

4554 SE Bridgetown Court | Willoughby Cay

$360,000

3 beds, 2 baths, 1,549sqft, $249/sqft

4585 SE Bridgetown Ct | Willoughby Plat No 18 A P

$375,000

3 beds, 2 baths, 1,549sqft, $243/sqft

1589 SE Tidewater Place | Willoughby Cay

$337,500

2 beds, 2 baths, 1,549sqft, $239/sqft

1577 SE Tidewater Place | Willoughby Plat No 18 A P

$335,000

2 beds, 2 baths, 1,416sqft, $234/sqft

1458 SE Tidewater Place | Willoughby 18 Willoughby Cay

$301,900

2 beds, 2 baths, 1,549sqft, $201/sqft

1600 SE Tidewater Place | Willoughby Plat No 18 A P

$3,500/mo

3 beds, 2 baths, 1,549sqft, $3/sqft

1505 SE Tidewater Place | Willoughby 18 Willoughby Cay

$3,000/mo

3 beds, 2 baths, 1,549sqft, $3/sqft

1452 SE Tidewater Place | Willoughby (aka Willoughb

$3,200/mo

3 beds, 2 baths, 1,549sqft, $3/sqft

1505 SE Tidewater Place | Willoughby 18 Willoughby Cay

$3,000/mo

3 beds, 2 baths, 1,549sqft, $3/sqft

1446 SE Tidewater Place | Willoughby Cay

$3,000/mo

3 beds, 2 baths, 1,549sqft, $3/sqft

4531 SE Bridgetown Court | Willoughby Cay

$2,900/mo

3 beds, 2 baths, 1,549sqft, $2/sqft

1505 SE Tidewater Place | Willoughby 18 Willoughby Cay

$3,000/mo

3 beds, 2 baths, 1,549sqft, $2/sqft

4531 SE Bridgetown Court | Willoughby 18 Willoughby Cay

$2,600/mo

3 beds, 2 baths, 1,549sqft, $2/sqft

1517 SE Tidewater Place | Willoughby Plat No 18 A P

$2,800/mo

3 beds, 2 baths, 1,549sqft, $2/sqft

1517 SE Tidewater Place | Willoughby Plat No 18 A P

$2,600/mo

3 beds, 2 baths, 1,700sqft, $2/sqft

View All 28 Sold Listings

Willoughby Cay Map

Loading map...

Willoughby Cay, Stuart, FL Homes for Sale

Willoughby Cay is a community in Stuart

How Much Is

My House Worth?

What's your home really worth?

Check your home's value for free

Willoughby Cay Market Status

Willoughby Cay, FL Market Report & Stats

Quick Community Stats for Willoughby Cay Loading...

Percentage reflects Change

Updated for May	May 2025	May 2024May 2023	% Diff
Avg Sold Price	-	--	--
New Properties on Market	-	--	--
Sold % of Ask Price	-	--	--
Avg Sold Price/SqFt	-	--	--

Market Report & Stats

Local Information

27 SEP

MAKE YOUR HOME SEXY AGAIN!

Cost Comparison

View Comparison Chart

How Much Is

My House Worth?

Determine your home's estimated value based on recent home sales in your area

Find Willoughby Cay Homes

Willoughby Cay Homes for Sale
Willoughby Cay Homes for Rent

Willoughby Cay $400,000 - $750,000
Willoughby Cay $750,000 - $1,000,000

Willoughby Cay $1,000,000 - $2,000,000
Willoughby Cay $2,000,000 and up

View All Communities

Nearby Communities

800 Place Stuart
Tropical Fruit Farms
Frazier Creek
Townhomes of Stuart
Tierra Verde Stuart

Tall Pines Stuart
River Glen
River Forest
Palmetto Harbor

Days on MarketDOM

41Days | 11%

Active InventoryAI

6,503 Homes | 30%

Median Sales PriceMSP

$645,000 | -1%

New ListingsNL

1,839 Homes | 1%

Closed SalesCS

1,328 Homes | -5%

Dollar VolumeDV

$1.6B | 0%

Months of InventoryMOI

5.9 Months | 34%

Pending SalesCS

1,336 Homes | -10%

Willoughby Cay