Artboard 1? alert-icon? Artboard 1? ? ? delete-icon? edit-icon? email-icon hide-hover-icon? Artboard 1? login-icon-white Artboard 1? next-icon-left next-icon-right-left next-icon-left-ochre next-icon next-icon-right-grey next-icon-right-ochre plus-with-circle-iconP search-fw-icon? search-icon-ochre search-icon-white
×

Select Language

Surprise Lake

A subdivision of Nautilus.

Total Homes : 201

Percentage Available: 4 %

Gated : No

Club Membership : No

No-Fee Community : No

Surprise Lake, Miami Beach, FL Homes for Sale

LOCATION PRICE BEDS BATHS $/SQFT
4534 Sheridan Ave | Surprise Lake $6,350,000 5 6/1 $1,696 -
4504 Sheridan Ave | Surprise Lake $5,400,000 5 4/2 $1,482 -
4430 Royal Palm Ave | Orchard Sub No 4 $4,195,000 4 3/1 $1,596 -
4580 Post Ave | Surprise Lake $3,900,000 4 3 $1,391 -
4490 Royal Palm Ave | Orchard Sub No 4 $2,699,000 4 3/1 $1,133 -
4500 Sheridan Ave | Surprise Lake $2,295,000 3 2 $1,477 -
4575 Post Ave | Surprise Lake $2,190,000 4 4/2 $787 -
4501 Prairie Ave #1 | The Ewing Condo $890,000 3 1/1 $639 -
LOCATION PRICE BEDS BATHS $/SQFT
345 W 46th St #345 | Surprise Lake $35,000/mo 4 4/1 $10 -
4504 Sheridan Ave | Surprise Lake $32,000/mo 5 4/2 $9 -
4430 Royal Palm Ave | Orchard Sub No 4 $25,000/mo 4 3/1 $10 -
4582 Royal Palm Ave | Surprise Lake $5,400/mo 3 2/1 $3 -
LOCATION PRICE BEDS BATHS $/SQFT
4534 Sheridan Ave | Surprise Lake $6,350,000 5 6/1 $1,696 -
4504 Sheridan Ave | Surprise Lake $5,400,000 5 4/2 $1,482 -
4430 Royal Palm Ave | Orchard Sub No 4 $4,195,000 4 3/1 $1,596 -
4580 Post Ave | Surprise Lake $3,900,000 4 3 $1,391 -
4490 Royal Palm Ave | Orchard Sub No 4 $2,699,000 4 3/1 $1,133 -
4500 Sheridan Ave | Surprise Lake $2,295,000 3 2 $1,477 -
4575 Post Ave | Surprise Lake $2,190,000 4 4/2 $787 -
4501 Prairie Ave #1 | The Ewing Condo $890,000 3 1/1 $639 -
345 W 46th St #345 | Surprise Lake $35,000/mo 4 4/1 $10 -
4504 Sheridan Ave | Surprise Lake $32,000/mo 5 4/2 $9 -
4430 Royal Palm Ave | Orchard Sub No 4 $25,000/mo 4 3/1 $10 -
4582 Royal Palm Ave | Surprise Lake $5,400/mo 3 2/1 $3 -
LOCATION PRICE BEDS BATHS $/SQFT
335 W 46th St | Surprise Lake $3,650,000 4 4/1 $1,307 -
4532 Sheridan Ave | Surprise Lake $3,000,000 4 4 $1,178 -
4580 Post Ave | Surprise Lake $2,850,000 4 3 $1,068 -
4630 Royal Palm Ave | Surprise Lake $2,830,000 6 4 $864 -
4484 Royal Palm Ave | Orchard Sub No 4 $2,300,000 3 3 $1,330 -
356 W 46th St | Surprise Lake $2,490,000 0 0 $445 -
4531 Post Ave | Surprise Lake $1,875,000 3 2 $1,215 -
4444 Sheridan Ave | Orchard Sub No 4 $1,825,000 4 3 $769 -
4430 Royal Palm Ave | Orchard Sub No 4 $1,720,000 4 4 $808 -
4531 Post Ave | Surprise Lake $1,525,000 3 2 $1,102 -
4601 Royal Palm Ave | Surprise Lake $1,700,000 0 0 0 -
4601 Royal Palm Ave | Surprise Lake $1,700,000 3 2 $964 -
4412 Royal Palm Ave | Orchard Sub No 4 $1,550,000 3 2 $1,150 -
4582 Royal Palm Ave | Surprise Lake $1,700,000 2 2 $913 -
524 W 47th Street | Surprise Lake Sub $1,580,000 4 2 $785 -
634 W 47th St | Surprise Lake $19,000/mo 5 4 $8 -
4437 Sheridan Ave | Orchard Sub No 4 $17,500/mo 3 3 $11 -
4532 Sheridan Ave | Surprise Lake $16,200/mo 4 4 $6 -
4630 Royal Palm Ave | Surprise Lake $16,000/mo 6 4 $5 -
4491 Prairie Ave | Orchard Sub No 4 $15,000/mo 5 3/1 $5 -
4630 Royal Palm Ave | Surprise Lake $12,200/mo 6 4 $4 -
4544 Post Ave #A | Surprise Lake $10,750/mo 3 3 $6 -
427 W 45th St # | Surprise Lake $9,000/mo 4 3 $4 -
4531 Sheridan Ave #. | Surprise Lake $7,250/mo 4 2 $5 -
4531 Prairie Ave #2 | Surprise Lake $7,200/mo 3 2 $3 -
4531 Prairie Ave #2 | Surprise Lake $7,000/mo 3 2 $3 -
4501 Prairie Ave #8 | The Ewing Condo $1,950/mo 1 1 $3 -

4534 Sheridan Ave | Surprise Lake

$6,350,000

5 beds, 6/1 baths, 3,746sqft, $1,696/sqft

4504 Sheridan Ave | Surprise Lake

$5,400,000

5 beds, 4/2 baths, 3,646sqft, $1,482/sqft

4430 Royal Palm Ave | Orchard Sub No 4

$4,195,000

4 beds, 3/1 baths, 2,629sqft, $1,596/sqft

4580 Post Ave | Surprise Lake

$3,900,000

4 beds, 3 baths, 2,805sqft, $1,391/sqft

4490 Royal Palm Ave | Orchard Sub No 4

$2,699,000

4 beds, 3/1 baths, 2,384sqft, $1,133/sqft

4500 Sheridan Ave | Surprise Lake

$2,295,000

3 beds, 2 baths, 1,554sqft, $1,477/sqft

4575 Post Ave | Surprise Lake

$2,190,000

4 beds, 4/2 baths, 2,783sqft, $787/sqft

4501 Prairie Ave #1 | The Ewing Condo

$890,000

3 beds, 1/1 baths, 1,393sqft, $639/sqft

345 W 46th St #345 | Surprise Lake

$35,000/mo

4 beds, 4/1 baths, 3,743sqft, $10/sqft

4504 Sheridan Ave | Surprise Lake

$32,000/mo

5 beds, 4/2 baths, 3,646sqft, $9/sqft

4430 Royal Palm Ave | Orchard Sub No 4

$25,000/mo

4 beds, 3/1 baths, 2,629sqft, $10/sqft

4582 Royal Palm Ave | Surprise Lake

$5,400/mo

3 beds, 2/1 baths, 1,864sqft, $3/sqft

4534 Sheridan Ave | Surprise Lake

$6,350,000

5 beds, 6/1 baths, 3,746sqft, $1,696/sqft

4504 Sheridan Ave | Surprise Lake

$5,400,000

5 beds, 4/2 baths, 3,646sqft, $1,482/sqft

4430 Royal Palm Ave | Orchard Sub No 4

$4,195,000

4 beds, 3/1 baths, 2,629sqft, $1,596/sqft

4580 Post Ave | Surprise Lake

$3,900,000

4 beds, 3 baths, 2,805sqft, $1,391/sqft

4490 Royal Palm Ave | Orchard Sub No 4

$2,699,000

4 beds, 3/1 baths, 2,384sqft, $1,133/sqft

4500 Sheridan Ave | Surprise Lake

$2,295,000

3 beds, 2 baths, 1,554sqft, $1,477/sqft

4575 Post Ave | Surprise Lake

$2,190,000

4 beds, 4/2 baths, 2,783sqft, $787/sqft

4501 Prairie Ave #1 | The Ewing Condo

$890,000

3 beds, 1/1 baths, 1,393sqft, $639/sqft

345 W 46th St #345 | Surprise Lake

$35,000/mo

4 beds, 4/1 baths, 3,743sqft, $10/sqft

4504 Sheridan Ave | Surprise Lake

$32,000/mo

5 beds, 4/2 baths, 3,646sqft, $9/sqft

4430 Royal Palm Ave | Orchard Sub No 4

$25,000/mo

4 beds, 3/1 baths, 2,629sqft, $10/sqft

4582 Royal Palm Ave | Surprise Lake

$5,400/mo

3 beds, 2/1 baths, 1,864sqft, $3/sqft

335 W 46th St | Surprise Lake

$3,650,000

4 beds, 4/1 baths, 3,053sqft, $1,307/sqft

4532 Sheridan Ave | Surprise Lake

$3,000,000

4 beds, 4 baths, 2,969sqft, $1,178/sqft

4580 Post Ave | Surprise Lake

$2,850,000

4 beds, 3 baths, 2,805sqft, $1,068/sqft

4630 Royal Palm Ave | Surprise Lake

$2,830,000

6 beds, 4 baths, 3,347sqft, $864/sqft

4484 Royal Palm Ave | Orchard Sub No 4

$2,300,000

3 beds, 3 baths, 1,877sqft, $1,330/sqft

356 W 46th St | Surprise Lake

$2,490,000

5,608sqft, $445/sqft

4531 Post Ave | Surprise Lake

$1,875,000

3 beds, 2 baths, 1,725sqft, $1,215/sqft

4444 Sheridan Ave | Orchard Sub No 4

$1,825,000

4 beds, 3 baths, 2,602sqft, $769/sqft

4430 Royal Palm Ave | Orchard Sub No 4

$1,720,000

4 beds, 4 baths, 2,464sqft, $808/sqft

4531 Post Ave | Surprise Lake

$1,525,000

3 beds, 2 baths, 1,725sqft, $1,102/sqft

4601 Royal Palm Ave | Surprise Lake

$1,700,000

3 beds, 2 baths, 1,966sqft, $964/sqft

4412 Royal Palm Ave | Orchard Sub No 4

$1,550,000

3 beds, 2 baths, 1,544sqft, $1,150/sqft

4582 Royal Palm Ave | Surprise Lake

$1,700,000

2 beds, 2 baths, 1,864sqft, $913/sqft

524 W 47th Street | Surprise Lake Sub

$1,580,000

4 beds, 2 baths, 2,071sqft, $785/sqft

634 W 47th St | Surprise Lake

$19,000/mo

5 beds, 4 baths, 2,568sqft, $8/sqft

4437 Sheridan Ave | Orchard Sub No 4

$17,500/mo

3 beds, 3 baths, 1,843sqft, $11/sqft

4532 Sheridan Ave | Surprise Lake

$16,200/mo

4 beds, 4 baths, 2,969sqft, $6/sqft

4630 Royal Palm Ave | Surprise Lake

$16,000/mo

6 beds, 4 baths, 3,347sqft, $5/sqft

4491 Prairie Ave | Orchard Sub No 4

$15,000/mo

5 beds, 3/1 baths, 3,326sqft, $5/sqft

4630 Royal Palm Ave | Surprise Lake

$12,200/mo

6 beds, 4 baths, 3,445sqft, $4/sqft

4544 Post Ave #A | Surprise Lake

$10,750/mo

3 beds, 3 baths, 1,841sqft, $6/sqft

427 W 45th St # | Surprise Lake

$9,000/mo

4 beds, 3 baths, 2,673sqft, $4/sqft

4531 Sheridan Ave #. | Surprise Lake

$7,250/mo

4 beds, 2 baths, 1,855sqft, $5/sqft

4531 Prairie Ave #2 | Surprise Lake

$7,200/mo

3 beds, 2 baths, 2,500sqft, $3/sqft

4531 Prairie Ave #2 | Surprise Lake

$7,000/mo

3 beds, 2 baths, 2,500sqft, $3/sqft

4501 Prairie Ave #8 | The Ewing Condo

$1,950/mo

1 beds, 1 baths, 700sqft, $3/sqft

Surprise Lake Map

Loading map...

Surprise Lake: A Welcoming Community in Miami Beach 

A well-established and quaint neighborhood in the center of Miami Beach, Florida, Surprise Lake is renowned for its opulent residences, historic charm, and tranquil setting. Founded in 1924, this upscale neighborhood has gradually grown into a sought-after destination with a wide range of house styles and architectural ideas. For professionals, families, and anybody else seeking a calm Miami Beach lifestyle, it has grown to be a popular location. Along with first-rate amenities that improve convenience and the quality of life overall, residents also have easy access to parks, neighborhood stores, and recreational spaces. 

Find Your Home in Surprise Lake 

Surprise Lake homes for sale provide residents a warm and inviting environment with a stunning fusion of modern luxury and old world charm. The bulk of the neighborhood is made up of large single-family homes with original architectural styles and spacious layouts. The houses range in size from 1,300 to over 3,600 square feet, offering possibilities to accommodate a variety of family sizes and tastes. From a cozy 2-bedroom retreat to an opulent 6-bedroom home, Surprise Lake has a variety of options to suit your needs. All inhabitants are guaranteed comfort and solitude in these residences, which frequently have two to five baths. 

With over 201 single-family houses, Surprise Lake is a large but tight-knit community. Numerous homes have undergone careful renovations while maintaining their original appeal, providing a fusion of contemporary amenities and vintage charm. There are many lovely designs available to potential homeowners, such as large living spaces, lush landscape, and opulent finishing. Surprise Lake is a great spot to begin your search for a high-value house in a neighborhood renowned for its elegance and history. 

Local Highlights and Amenities 

Surprise Lake’s prime position within Miami Beach is one of its main draws. Pine Tree Park and Indian Beach Park, two of the area’s top recreational areas, are only a short drive from the neighborhood. Residents can enjoy a variety of outdoor activities, beautiful walking routes, and lush green spaces in these parks. Golfers will value being close to the well-known Miami Beach Golf Club, which has a top-notch course and breathtaking views. Furthermore, Alton Plaza, which has a range of stores, restaurants, and necessary services, is near to the area. 

Families living in the homes for sale at Surprise Lake benefit from access to highly-rated schools, such as North Beach Elementary School, Miami Beach Nautilus Middle School, and Nautilus High School. Healthcare needs are also well-served, with Mount Sinai Medical Center just a short drive away. Pet owners can rest easy knowing that Banfield Pet Hospital is conveniently located nearby. Living in Surprise Lake means being within reach of everything Miami Beach has to offer, while still enjoying the comfort and charm of a peaceful residential community. 

Surprise Lake FAQs  

1. What types of homes are available in Surprise Lake? 
Surprise Lake offers a variety of single-family homes ranging from 1,300 to over 3,600 square feet, with options for 2 to 6 bedrooms and 2 to 5 bathrooms.
2. Is Surprise Lake pet-friendly? 
Yes, the community is pet-friendly, with nearby parks and pet services like Banfield Pet Hospital located within a short distance.
3. What makes Surprise Lake a desirable community in Miami Beach? 
Surprise Lake’s combination of luxurious homes, rich history, prime location, and proximity to amenities like parks, schools, and healthcare facilities makes it a highly desirable neighborhood for families and professionals.
4. Is healthcare easily accessible from Surprise Lake? 
Yes, the community is close to Mount Sinai Medical Center, providing convenient access to healthcare services.

Surprise Lake Market Status

Surprise Lake, FL Market Report & Stats

Quick Community Stats for Surprise Lake Loading...

Percentage reflects Change

Updated for May May 2026 May 2025May 2024 % Diff
Avg Sold Price - -- --
New Properties on Market - -- --
Sold % of Ask Price - -- --
Avg Sold Price/SqFt - -- --
View All Communities

Ask Questions

Jeff Lichtenstein's Echo Fine Properties

ECHO FINE PROPERTIES

C 561-500-3246

O 561-500-3246

F 561-277-2500

Request More Info

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Your Soulmate in Real Estate™

Looking for a Perfect Community to live?

Take our step by step quiz to find a best matching community for you*.

* Patent Pending