Surprise Lake

A subdivision of Nautilus.

Total Homes : 201

Percentage Available: 5.5 %

Gated : No

Club Membership : No

No-Fee Community : No

See All Listings Active Homes for Sale>

See All Listings Active Homes for Sale

Surprise Lake, Miami Beach, FL Homes for Sale

Virtual Tour

25 Photos

4485 Post Ave Miami Beach, FL 33140

5 Beds / 4/1 Baths / 3,351 Sqft

$4,675,000

Surprise Lake

46 Photos

4504 Sheridan Ave Miami Beach, FL 33140

5 Beds / 4/2 Baths / 3,646 Sqft

$6,450,000

Surprise Lake

36 Photos

4485 Royal Palm Ave Miami Beach, FL 33140

6 Beds / 5 Baths / 3,978 Sqft

$4,989,000

Surprise Lake

47 Photos

345 W 46th St #345 Miami Beach, FL 33140

4 Beds / 4/1 Baths / 3,743 Sqft

$36,900/mo

Surprise Lake

46 Photos

335 W 46th St Miami Beach, FL 33140

4 Beds / 4/1 Baths / 2,882 Sqft

$34,900/mo

Surprise Lake

54 Photos

4580 Post Ave Miami Beach, FL 33140

3 Beds / 2 Baths / 2,835 Sqft

$25,000/mo

Surprise Lake

PENDING

46 Photos

4430 Royal Palm Ave Miami Beach, FL 33140

4 Beds / 4 Baths / 2,464 Sqft

$1,989,000

Surprise Lake

PENDING

28 Photos

4437 Sheridan Ave Miami Beach, FL 33140

3 Beds / 3 Baths / 1,843 Sqft

$19,000/mo

Surprise Lake

PENDING

41 Photos

4630 Royal Palm Ave Miami Beach, FL 33140

6 Beds / 4 Baths / 3,347 Sqft

$12,500/mo

Surprise Lake

SOLD

0 Photos

4560 Sheridan Ave Miami Beach, FL 33140

4 Beds / 4 Baths / 3,786 Sqft

$7,200,000

Surprise Lake

SOLD

0 Photos

4459 Sheridan Ave Miami Beach, FL 33140

5 Beds / 4 Baths / 2,811 Sqft

$3,360,000

Surprise Lake

SOLD

25 Photos

4630 Royal Palm Ave Miami Beach, FL 33140

6 Beds / 4 Baths / 3,347 Sqft

$2,830,000

Surprise Lake

LOCATION	PRICE	BEDS	BATHS	$/SQFT
4504 Sheridan Ave \| Surprise Lake	$6,450,000	5	4/2	$1,770	-
4485 Royal Palm Ave \| Orchard Sub No 4	$4,989,000	6	5	$1,255	-
335 W 46th St \| Surprise Lake	$4,770,000	4	4/1	$1,455	-
Virtual Tour - 4485 Post Ave \| Orchard Sub No 4	$4,675,000	5	4/1	$1,396	Virtual Tour
670 W 46 Street \| Surprise Lake Sub	$3,300,000	0	0	$470	-
4490 Royal Palm Ave \| Orchard Sub No 4	$3,000,000	4	3/1	$1,259	-
624 W 47th St \| Surprise Lake	$2,750,000	4	4	$1,095	-
Virtual Tour - 4484 Royal Palm Ave \| Orchard Sub No 4	$2,599,999	3	3	$1,335	Virtual Tour

View All 8 Listings For Sale

LOCATION	PRICE	BEDS	BATHS	$/SQFT
345 W 46th St #345 \| Surprise Lake	$36,900/mo	4	4/1	$10	-
335 W 46th St \| Surprise Lake	$34,900/mo	4	4/1	$13	-
4580 Post Ave \| Surprise Lake	$25,000/mo	3	2	$9	-
4501 Prairie Ave #8 \| The Ewing Condo	$1,990/mo	1	1	$4	-

View All 4 Rentals

LOCATION	PRICE	BEDS	BATHS	$/SQFT
4430 Royal Palm Ave \| Orchard Sub No 4	$1,989,000	4	4	$808	-
4437 Sheridan Ave \| Orchard Sub No 4	$19,000/mo	3	3	$11	-
4630 Royal Palm Ave \| Surprise Lake	$12,500/mo	6	4	$4	-

View All 3 Pending Listings

LOCATION	PRICE	BEDS	BATHS	$/SQFT
4560 Sheridan Ave \| Surprise Lake	$7,200,000	4	4	$1,797	-
4459 Sheridan Ave \| Orchard Sub No 4	$3,360,000	5	4	$1,192	-
4630 Royal Palm Ave \| Surprise Lake	$2,830,000	6	4	$864	-
4560 Royal Palm Ave \| Surprise Lake	$2,450,000	3	3	$1,367	-
356 W 46th St \| Surprise Lake	$2,490,000	0	0	$445	-
4568 Post Ave \| Surprise Lake	$2,275,000	3	2	$1,172	-
4427 Royal Palm Ave \| Orchard Sub No 4	$1,980,000	4	3	$1,145	-
4531 Post Ave \| Surprise Lake	$1,875,000	3	2	$1,215	-
4630 Royal Palm Ave \| Surprise Lake	$1,999,000	6	4	$598	-
4444 Sheridan Ave \| Orchard Sub No 4	$1,825,000	4	3	$769	-
4501 Royal Palm Ave \| Surprise Lake	$2,200,000	4	3/1	$802	-
4643 Prairie Ave \| Surprise Lake	$1,850,000	4	4	$790	-
4531 Post Ave \| Surprise Lake	$1,525,000	3	2	$1,102	-
4531 Sheridan Ave \| Surprise Lake	$1,750,000	4	2	$1,022	-
4526 Post Ave \| Surprise Lake	$1,550,000	3	2	$1,010	-
4504 Sheridan Ave \| Surprise Lake	$1,800,000	4	2/1	$825	-
4515 Royal Palm Ave \| Surprise Lake	$1,730,000	2	2	$925	-
4551 Prairie Ave \| Surprise Lake	$1,600,000	3	2/1	$1,020	-
524 W 47th St \| Surprise Lake Sub	$1,580,000	4	2	$785	-
4560 Post Ave \| Surprise Lake	$1,500,000	4	3	$549	-
345 W 46th St \| Surprise Lake	$1,200,000	5	4/1	0	-
4527 Sheridan Ave \| Surprise Lake	$1,445,000	4	3	$589	-
4534 Sheridan Ave \| Surprise Lake	$990,000	4	4	$453	-
4501 Prairie Ave #5 \| The Ewing Condo	$684,999	2	1/1	$515	-
4459 Sheridan Ave \| Orchard Sub No 4	$25,000/mo	5	4	$18	-
335 W 46th St \| Surprise Lake	$35,000/mo	4	4/1	$16	-
4532 Sheridan Ave \| Surprise Lake	$16,200/mo	4	4	$6	-
4630 Royal Palm Ave \| Surprise Lake	$16,000/mo	6	4	$5	-
4544 Post Ave #A \| Surprise Lake	$10,750/mo	3	3	$6	-
427 W 45th St # \| Surprise Lake	$9,000/mo	4	3	$4	-
4531 Sheridan Ave #. \| Surprise Lake	$7,250/mo	4	2	$5	-
4531 Prairie Ave #2 \| Surprise Lake	$7,500/mo	3	2	$4	-
4531 Prairie Ave #1 \| Surprise Lake	$7,350/mo	3	2	$4	-
4511 Royal Palm Ave \| Surprise Lake	$7,500/mo	3	2	$4	-
4531 Prairie Ave #2 \| Surprise Lake	$7,200/mo	3	2	$3	-
4531 Prairie Ave #2 \| Surprise Lake	$7,000/mo	3	2	$3	-
4531 Prairie Ave #1 \| Surprise Lake	$6,500/mo	3	2	$3	-
527 W 46th St #1 \| Surprise Lake	$4,900/mo	3	2	$3	-
4420 Royal Palm Ave #Studio \| Orchard Sub No 4	$1,600/mo	0	1	$9	-

View All 39 Sold Listings

4504 Sheridan Ave | Surprise Lake

$6,450,000

5 beds, 4/2 baths, 3,646sqft, $1,770/sqft

4485 Royal Palm Ave | Orchard Sub No 4

$4,989,000

6 beds, 5 baths, 3,978sqft, $1,255/sqft

335 W 46th St | Surprise Lake

$4,770,000

4 beds, 4/1 baths, 3,280sqft, $1,455/sqft

Virtual Tour - 4485 Post Ave | Orchard Sub No 4

$4,675,000

5 beds, 4/1 baths, 3,351sqft, $1,396/sqft

670 W 46 Street | Surprise Lake Sub

$3,300,000

7,026sqft, $470/sqft

4490 Royal Palm Ave | Orchard Sub No 4

$3,000,000

4 beds, 3/1 baths, 2,384sqft, $1,259/sqft

624 W 47th St | Surprise Lake

$2,750,000

4 beds, 4 baths, 2,513sqft, $1,095/sqft

Virtual Tour - 4484 Royal Palm Ave | Orchard Sub No 4

$2,599,999

3 beds, 3 baths, 1,949sqft, $1,335/sqft

View All 8 Listings For Sale

345 W 46th St #345 | Surprise Lake

$36,900/mo

4 beds, 4/1 baths, 3,743sqft, $10/sqft

335 W 46th St | Surprise Lake

$34,900/mo

4 beds, 4/1 baths, 2,882sqft, $13/sqft

4580 Post Ave | Surprise Lake

$25,000/mo

3 beds, 2 baths, 2,835sqft, $9/sqft

4501 Prairie Ave #8 | The Ewing Condo

$1,990/mo

1 beds, 1 baths, 630sqft, $4/sqft

View All 4 Rentals

4430 Royal Palm Ave | Orchard Sub No 4

$1,989,000

4 beds, 4 baths, 2,464sqft, $808/sqft

4437 Sheridan Ave | Orchard Sub No 4

$19,000/mo

3 beds, 3 baths, 1,843sqft, $11/sqft

4630 Royal Palm Ave | Surprise Lake

$12,500/mo

6 beds, 4 baths, 3,347sqft, $4/sqft

View All 3 Pending Listings

4560 Sheridan Ave | Surprise Lake

$7,200,000

4 beds, 4 baths, 3,786sqft, $1,797/sqft

4459 Sheridan Ave | Orchard Sub No 4

$3,360,000

5 beds, 4 baths, 2,811sqft, $1,192/sqft

4630 Royal Palm Ave | Surprise Lake

$2,830,000

6 beds, 4 baths, 3,347sqft, $864/sqft

4560 Royal Palm Ave | Surprise Lake

$2,450,000

3 beds, 3 baths, 1,902sqft, $1,367/sqft

356 W 46th St | Surprise Lake

$2,490,000

5,608sqft, $445/sqft

4568 Post Ave | Surprise Lake

$2,275,000

3 beds, 2 baths, 2,044sqft, $1,172/sqft

4427 Royal Palm Ave | Orchard Sub No 4

$1,980,000

4 beds, 3 baths, 1,922sqft, $1,145/sqft

4531 Post Ave | Surprise Lake

$1,875,000

3 beds, 2 baths, 1,725sqft, $1,215/sqft

4630 Royal Palm Ave | Surprise Lake

$1,999,000

6 beds, 4 baths, 3,347sqft, $598/sqft

4444 Sheridan Ave | Orchard Sub No 4

$1,825,000

4 beds, 3 baths, 2,602sqft, $769/sqft

4501 Royal Palm Ave | Surprise Lake

$2,200,000

4 beds, 3/1 baths, 2,465sqft, $802/sqft

4643 Prairie Ave | Surprise Lake

$1,850,000

4 beds, 4 baths, 2,470sqft, $790/sqft

4531 Post Ave | Surprise Lake

$1,525,000

3 beds, 2 baths, 1,725sqft, $1,102/sqft

4531 Sheridan Ave | Surprise Lake

$1,750,000

4 beds, 2 baths, 1,855sqft, $1,022/sqft

4526 Post Ave | Surprise Lake

$1,550,000

3 beds, 2 baths, 1,873sqft, $1,010/sqft

4504 Sheridan Ave | Surprise Lake

$1,800,000

4 beds, 2/1 baths, 2,256sqft, $825/sqft

4515 Royal Palm Ave | Surprise Lake

$1,730,000

2 beds, 2 baths, 1,945sqft, $925/sqft

4551 Prairie Ave | Surprise Lake

$1,600,000

3 beds, 2/1 baths, 1,716sqft, $1,020/sqft

524 W 47th St | Surprise Lake Sub

$1,580,000

4 beds, 2 baths, 2,071sqft, $785/sqft

4560 Post Ave | Surprise Lake

$1,500,000

4 beds, 3 baths, 2,733sqft, $549/sqft

345 W 46th St | Surprise Lake

$1,200,000

5 beds, 4/1 baths,

4527 Sheridan Ave | Surprise Lake

$1,445,000

4 beds, 3 baths, 2,257sqft, $589/sqft

4534 Sheridan Ave | Surprise Lake

$990,000

4 beds, 4 baths, 2,187sqft, $453/sqft

4501 Prairie Ave #5 | The Ewing Condo

$684,999

2 beds, 1/1 baths, 1,420sqft, $515/sqft

4459 Sheridan Ave | Orchard Sub No 4

$25,000/mo

5 beds, 4 baths, 2,811sqft, $18/sqft

335 W 46th St | Surprise Lake

$35,000/mo

4 beds, 4/1 baths, 2,882sqft, $16/sqft

4532 Sheridan Ave | Surprise Lake

$16,200/mo

4 beds, 4 baths, 2,969sqft, $6/sqft

4630 Royal Palm Ave | Surprise Lake

$16,000/mo

6 beds, 4 baths, 3,347sqft, $5/sqft

4544 Post Ave #A | Surprise Lake

$10,750/mo

3 beds, 3 baths, 1,841sqft, $6/sqft

427 W 45th St # | Surprise Lake

$9,000/mo

4 beds, 3 baths, 2,673sqft, $4/sqft

4531 Sheridan Ave #. | Surprise Lake

$7,250/mo

4 beds, 2 baths, 1,855sqft, $5/sqft

4531 Prairie Ave #2 | Surprise Lake

$7,500/mo

3 beds, 2 baths, 2,500sqft, $4/sqft

4531 Prairie Ave #1 | Surprise Lake

$7,350/mo

3 beds, 2 baths, 2,500sqft, $4/sqft

4511 Royal Palm Ave | Surprise Lake

$7,500/mo

3 beds, 2 baths, 2,377sqft, $4/sqft

4531 Prairie Ave #2 | Surprise Lake

$7,200/mo

3 beds, 2 baths, 2,500sqft, $3/sqft

4531 Prairie Ave #2 | Surprise Lake

$7,000/mo

3 beds, 2 baths, 2,500sqft, $3/sqft

4531 Prairie Ave #1 | Surprise Lake

$6,500/mo

3 beds, 2 baths, 2,500sqft, $3/sqft

527 W 46th St #1 | Surprise Lake

$4,900/mo

3 beds, 2 baths, 2,000sqft, $3/sqft

4420 Royal Palm Ave #Studio | Orchard Sub No 4

$1,600/mo

1 baths, 200sqft, $9/sqft

View All 39 Sold Listings

Surprise Lake Map

Loading map...

Surprise Lake, Miami Beach, FL Homes for Sale

Situated on the Mid-Beach area of Miami Beach, Surprise Lake is close to the beach and Miami Beach Golf Club, as well as abundant shops and restaurants. The community of Surprise Lake itself features a private dock and ocean access.

How Much Is

My House Worth?

What's your home really worth?

Check your home's value for free

Surprise Lake Market Status

Surprise Lake, FL Market Report & Stats

Quick Community Stats for Surprise Lake Loading...

Percentage reflects Change

Updated for June	Jun 2024	Jun 2023Jun 2022	% Diff
Avg Sold Price	-	--	--
New Properties on Market	-	--	--
Sold % of Ask Price	-	--	--
Avg Sold Price/SqFt	-	--	--

Market Report & Stats

Local Information

27 SEP

MAKE YOUR HOME SEXY AGAIN!

Cost Comparison

View Comparison Chart

How Much Is

My House Worth?

Determine your home's estimated value based on recent home sales in your area

Find Surprise Lake Homes

Surprise Lake Homes for Sale
Surprise Lake Homes for Rent

Surprise Lake $400,000 - $750,000
Surprise Lake $750,000 - $1,000,000

Surprise Lake $1,000,000 - $2,000,000
Surprise Lake $2,000,000 and up

View All Communities

Nearby Communities

Indian Beach
Flamingo Bay
Excelsior Condos
Ritz-Carlton Miami Beach

Days on MarketDOM

35Days | 35%

Active InventoryAI

5,170 Homes | 48%

Median Sales PriceMSP

$659,999 | 6%

New ListingsNL

1,640 Homes | 5%

Closed SalesCS

1,269 Homes | -11%

Dollar VolumeDV

$1.4B | -8%

Months of InventoryMOI

4.5 Months | 50%

Pending SalesCS

1,149 Homes | -10%

Surprise Lake