Artboard 1? alert-icon? Artboard 1? ? ? delete-icon? edit-icon? email-icon hide-hover-icon? Artboard 1? login-icon-white Artboard 1? next-icon-left next-icon-right-left next-icon-left-ochre next-icon next-icon-right-grey next-icon-right-ochre plus-with-circle-iconP search-fw-icon? search-icon-ochre search-icon-white
×

Select Language

Captains Creek

A subdivision of Palm City.

Total Homes : 100

Percentage Available: 2 %

Gated : No

Club Membership : No

No-Fee Community : No

Captains Creek, Palm City, FL Homes for Sale

LOCATION PRICE BEDS BATHS $/SQFT
5661 SW Orchid Bay Drive | Captains Creek (orchid Bay) $1,425,000 5 4 $315 -
5145 SW Spring Aster Court | Captains Creek $997,500 7 4 $252 -
LOCATION PRICE BEDS BATHS $/SQFT
5661 SW Orchid Bay Drive | Captains Creek (orchid Bay) $1,425,000 5 4 $315 -
5145 SW Spring Aster Court | Captains Creek $997,500 7 4 $252 -

5661 SW Orchid Bay Drive | Captains Creek (orchid Bay)

$1,425,000

5 beds, 4 baths, 4,538sqft, $315/sqft

5145 SW Spring Aster Court | Captains Creek

$997,500

7 beds, 4 baths, 3,967sqft, $252/sqft

5661 SW Orchid Bay Drive | Captains Creek (orchid Bay)

$1,425,000

5 beds, 4 baths, 4,538sqft, $315/sqft

5145 SW Spring Aster Court | Captains Creek

$997,500

7 beds, 4 baths, 3,967sqft, $252/sqft

1271 SW Robys Way | Captains Creek

$1,500,000

5 beds, 4 baths, 4,152sqft, $404/sqft

5570 SW Coral Tree Lane | Orchid Bay

$1,375,000

4 beds, 3/1 baths, 4,149sqft, $338/sqft

5002 SW Orchid Bay Drive | Orchid Bay

$1,130,000

4 beds, 3 baths, 2,956sqft, $403/sqft

5485 SW Orchid Bay Drive | Orchid Bay

$1,025,000

5 beds, 4/2 baths, 4,136sqft, $266/sqft

5530 SW Orchid Bay Drive | Orchid Bay

$885,000

4 beds, 3 baths, 2,817sqft, $373/sqft

1315 SW Robys Way | Orchid Bay, Captains Creek

$995,000

3 beds, 3 baths, 2,719sqft, $368/sqft

1392 SW Sea Holly Way | Orchid Bay

$910,000

4 beds, 2/1 baths, 2,659sqft, $358/sqft

1256 SW Jasmine Trace | Orchid Bay

$910,000

4 beds, 4 baths, 3,200sqft, $294/sqft

1480 SW Sea Holly Way | Orchid Bay

$812,500

3 beds, 3 baths, 3,003sqft, $289/sqft

5068 SW Orchid Bay Drive | Captain's Creek Plat Of

$800,000

4 beds, 3 baths, 2,610sqft, $322/sqft

1457 SW Sea Holly Way | Captains Creek

$845,000

3 beds, 2/1 baths, 2,475sqft, $314/sqft

5372 SW Coral Tree Lane | Orchid Bay, Captain's Creek

$710,000

4 beds, 3 baths, 2,868sqft, $264/sqft

5221 SW Orchid Bay Drive | Captains Creek

$680,000

3 beds, 2 baths, 2,124sqft, $325/sqft

Captains Creek Map

Loading map...

Discover the Lifestyle of Captains Creek Homes

Captains Creek offers a relaxed Palm City setting where everyday living feels easy and connected. Without the restrictions of a gated entrance, residents enjoy a more open neighborhood atmosphere while still benefiting from spacious homes and well-kept surroundings. The community appeals to those who value room to spread out, both inside and out, with homes designed for comfortable living and entertaining. Its location keeps you close to daily conveniences while preserving a quieter residential feel. Whether you’re heading out for a quick grocery run, meeting friends in nearby Stuart, or enjoying outdoor spaces, Captains Creek makes it simple to balance work, recreation, and downtime. 

About Captains Creek

Captains Creek is a non-gated residential community in Palm City known for its larger single-family homes and generous lot sizes. Homes typically range from 2,100 to 4,500 square feet, offering flexible layouts suited for a variety of lifestyles. 

Property features often include: 

  • 3 to 5 bedrooms 
  • 2 to 4 bathrooms 
  • Open living areas and functional floor plans 
  • Private outdoor spaces ideal for relaxing or entertaining 

The neighborhood’s design emphasizes space and comfort, giving homeowners the opportunity to personalize their properties while enjoying a cohesive community feel. 

History of Captains Creek

Captains Creek developed as Palm City grew into a desirable residential destination along Florida’s Treasure Coast. The community reflects a shift toward larger homes and suburban-style living, with an emphasis on space, accessibility, and proximity to natural surroundings. Over time, Palm City has maintained its reputation for a quieter pace compared to nearby coastal areas, and Captains Creek fits well within that identity. Its established setting continues to attract buyers looking for a balance between convenience and a more laid-back environment. 

Amenities

While Captains Creek is not a gated or amenity-heavy community, its appeal lies in location and nearby lifestyle options. Residents have easy access to a variety of local destinations: 

  • Downtown Stuart for dining, shopping, and waterfront activities 
  • Publix and everyday shopping centers nearby 
  • Halpatiokee Regional Park for hiking, biking, and nature trails 
  • Shepard Park for outdoor recreation and community events 
  • Quick access to major roadways for commuting 

Captains Creek FAQs

What types of Captains Creek Homes for Sale are available?

Captains Creek Homes for Sale typically include single-family residences with spacious layouts. Buyers can expect homes with 3 to 5 bedrooms and 2 to 4 bathrooms, with square footage ranging from approximately 2,100 to 4,500 square feet. Many properties offer flexible living spaces suited for both everyday use and entertaining. 

Is Captains Creek a gated community?

No, Captains Creek is not a gated community. This allows for easier access and a more open neighborhood feel while still maintaining a residential atmosphere. 

What schools serve Captains Creek?

Students in Captains Creek are generally zoned for: 

  • Bessey Creek Elementary School 
  • Hidden Oaks Middle School 
  • Martin County High School 

These schools are part of the Martin County School District and are located within a reasonable distance from the community. 

What is nearby Captains Creek?

Captains Creek is conveniently located near several key destinations, including Downtown Stuart for dining and entertainment, Publix for daily shopping, and parks like Halpatiokee Regional Park and Shepard Park for outdoor activities. 

Are there healthcare facilities near Captains Creek?

Yes, residents have access to nearby healthcare services, including Florida Coast Medical Center and Palm City Animal Medical Center, providing both medical and veterinary care close to home. 

Key Details

Captains Creek offers a residential setting focused on space, accessibility, and proximity to Palm City conveniences. The community is non-gated and features single-family homes with larger floor plans. 

Amenities 

  • Close to Downtown Stuart 
  • Nearby grocery stores including Publix 
  • Access to parks and outdoor recreation 
  • Convenient location within Palm City 

Community Fees 

  • Vary by property 
  • Typically include limited or no extensive amenity costs 

Membership Information 

  • No mandatory membership requirements 
  • No country club obligations 

Nearby Communities 

  • Evergreen Club – Known for its golf course setting and larger estate homes 
  • Copperleaf – A gated community with newer construction and modern layouts 
  • Riverbend – Offers a mix of condos and townhomes along the Loxahatchee River 

Work with Echo Fine Properties

If you’re interested in learning more about Captains Creek or exploring available homes, Echo Fine Properties offers local expertise and personalized guidance. From scheduling showings to understanding market trends, their team can help you navigate the process with confidence. Reach out today to explore current listings or get answers to your questions about Captains Creek in Palm City. 

Captains Creek Market Status

Captains Creek, FL Market Report & Stats

Quick Community Stats for Captains Creek Loading...

Percentage reflects Change

Updated for April Apr 2026 Apr 2025Apr 2024 % Diff
Avg Sold Price - -- --
New Properties on Market - -- --
Sold % of Ask Price - -- --
Avg Sold Price/SqFt - -- --
View All Communities

Ask Questions

Jeff Lichtenstein's Echo Fine Properties

ECHO FINE PROPERTIES

C 561-500-3246

O 561-500-3246

F 561-277-2500

Request More Info

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Your Soulmate in Real Estate™

Looking for a Perfect Community to live?

Take our step by step quiz to find a best matching community for you*.

* Patent Pending